Person
| Reason
|
[ Lives I envy... ]
|
|
Hermann Broch
| What he wrote (_The Sleepwalkers_, _The Death of Virgil_,
_Notes on the Problem of Kitsch_...): If I was who I wish I was, I would have
written many of the words he wrote.
|
Edmund Husserl
| What he thought (_Philosophy and the Crisis of European Humanity_...).
Showed how to go beyond equivocal "scientificness" of
Galilean sciences of nature, to self-accountability in all areas of life. Also a decent human being.
|
Thomas Mann
| Born to a "comfortable" life. Lived long and happily and honorably.
(Example that one does not need to suffer to be socially constructive or personally creative.)
|
Hans-Georg Gadamer
| Another deep humanistic philosopher (founded
modern phenomenological hermeneutics). Still working at age 100.
|
Giovanni de Dondi
| Spent 14 years, in the mid 14th century, constructing an
astronomical clock so advanced he had to invent many of the tools
to make it. He also thoroughly documented his work, so that, although his clock was soon
destroyed for scrap, reproductions of it could be reliably done in the 20th century.
|
Frank Lloyd Wright
| Not an ideal "family man". But right in assessing: "Early in life
I had to choose between false modesty and honest arrogance. I chose the latter and have
never regretted it."
|
Prince M. Masud R. Khan
| Unconventional psychoanalyst (incl. being Winnicott's literary secretary),
deeply cultured, and who used his wealth to help resolve some of his patient's
"psychological" problems (when the environment is making the patient sick, change the environment).
|
Marcel Duchamp
| (Would have been fun. "Why not sneeze?" "With hidden noise."....)
|
[ The good... ]
|
|
Donald Winnicott
| Gave infancy a voice (_Playing and Reality_,
_The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment_...).
|
Wanda Landowska
| Played the harpsichord (magisterially).
|
Louis Kahn
| Believed architecture should nourish persons and designed accordingly.
|
Roger Boisjoly
| Engineer who tried to prevent The Challenger disaster.
|
Oskar Schindler
| Saved Jews in WWII ("Schindler's List") -- but did not
pretend to be or try to make anyone else feel guilty about not being "a saint".
|
David Hume
| Skeptical philosopher who tried to
live consistent with his ideas, and was a good person all the way through a painful death.
|
Elliot Richardson
| Publicly resigned as Attorney-General rather than carry out
Richard Nixon's Watergate coverup orders.
|
Sun Tzu
| Military theoretician. ("The great general wins without fighting.")
|
Col. John R. Boyd
| Military theoretician (jet fighter combat). Based himself on Sun Tzu. Said way to win
a guerilla war is by offering the people a more appealing life than the guerillas offer.
I would feel good about America if all its military leaders were Boyds!
|
Joseph Needham
| _Science and Civilization in China_. Great and genuinely humanistic scholar.
|
Edward R. Murrow
| News reporter who brought Joseph McCarthy's terrorization of
the American people to an end, and exposed other social injustices.
|
Henry Heimlich
| Physician who invented "the Heimlich maneuver", which saves
people from choking to death, but costs nothing (better than a high rate of return
on investment, does not require investment).
|
Johannes Kepler
| Galileo's contemporary. Another great scientist; but apparently
more decent person than Galileo.
|
[ The irrelevant... ]
|
|
Elian Gonzales
| "Lightning rod" for United States - Cuban anamosities.
|
Lori Berenson
| Middle-class American who seems to have thought she could play "guerilla sympathizer"
in a right-wing third-world country (Peru), but then doesn't want to pay the price (a long
jail sentence, probably in unhealthful conditions).
|
Charles Lindberg
| Flew a plane across the Atlantic Ocean (somebody
else would have done it soon after if he hadn't).
|
Tiger Woods
| Preternaturally adept at hitting a golf ball where he wants it to go.
|
[ The dubious... ]
|
|
Leon Trotsky
| Real revolutionary or just another would-be dictator? (see Robert
Capa's "fractured" photo of Trotsky lecturing in Copenhagen, 1932)
|
John F. Kennedy
| Asked people to ask what they could do for their
country and not what their country could do for them, without first asking
whether their country had done enough for them (and not just for him...) to deserve this.
|
William J. Clinton
| Bright, well-intentioned ("socially progressive") product of a dysfunctional
childhood, who rose to become President of The United States, but could not
control his personal impulses, and thereby gave his adversaries the
means not just to defeat many of his policies, but also to enhance their own positions.
|
Socrates
| Died for what he believed in at an age when he may not have had
much longer to live anyway. Made people look foolish by asking them questions
he knew beforehand they couldn't possibly answer. Feigned ignorance.
|
Plato
| Great philosopher. Invented universal "pure ideas" to help preserve
the particular aristocratic form of life
he was part of. Tried to rewrite history to make his philosophical adversaries ("sophists")
look far worse than they were, and succeeded.
|
Aleksander Solzshenitsyn
| Made a lot of "moral hay" out of a relatively not so bad stint in The Gulag.
Believes in authoritarianism, just not the kind he doesn't like (Stalin's).
|
Martin Luther King
| Another equivocal "martyr" (indulged in silk shirts, etc.,
as well as in working for social justice).
|
Mother Theresa
| Seemed not just to love the poor, but to love them for being poor
(as opposed to helping them be poor no more).
|
Martin Heidegger
| Great philosopher (in his "Es gibt" part). Socially defective (probably did not
understand what Nazism was; thought he could teach Hitler the real meaning
of National Socialism...). Hypocrite (ranted against
"technology", but liked to fly in commercial airplanes, etc.).
|
Sigmund Freud
| Hermeneuticist or psycho-physicist?
|
Franklin Roosevelt
| Prevented capitalism from self-destructing in America in the
early 1930s, by alleviating much of the human suffering that process was causing (but not fixing the
root cause, i.e., capitalism itself: the form of social life which by its very nature is
always out of control). May not have tried as hard as he could to prevent "Pearl Harbor" (thousands of
innocent lives lost), to help get America into World War II.
|
Theodore Kaczynski (AKA The Unabomber)
| Murdered innocent people to try to
stop technology hurting us.
|
Galileo Galilei
| Invented modern exact mathematical sciences of nature. Prevented
this "science" from including critical reconstruction of social life,
via example of cowardly abandonment of truth when threatened with
torture by The Holy Office of the Inquisition, of The Roman Catholic Church,
after having "asked for it" by making a fool of the previously friendly-to-him
pope, in a book comparing Copernican, Tychonic and Ptolemaic cosmologies.
Demanded persons accept more of his new ideas than he justified to them. Dogmatic Copernican?
|
J. Robert Oppenheimer
| Great manager of scientific research ("father of the atomic bomb") and highly cultured
person, but who betrayed a friend (Haakan Chevalier) when he felt
threatened by "The powers that be" (American anti-communist "witch hunting").
|
A. Bartlett Giamatti
| Bad: Set bad example for children by leaving Presidency of Yale University
to become Commissioner of Baseball. Good: As Commissioner, brought high ethical standards and culture to
the sport of baseball.
|
[ The bad and the worse... ]
|
|
John Akers
| Helped the sun set on IBM (could, instead, have
recognized his incompetence and led the company to seek a more able leader
with better prospects to help it through difficult times).
|
William Turner
| Captain of the Lusitania ("At 8.00am speed was reduced to 18 knots
to secure the ship's arrival at the
bar outside Liverpool at 4.00am the following day, in order to catch the high tide.").
|
Edward John Smith
| Captain of the Titanic ("I cannot conceive
of any vital disaster happening to this vessel. Modern shipbuilding has gone beyond that.").
A sense of honor is good, but it is not a substitute for good sense.
|
Jeremy Bentham
| Invented the "panopticon" (cost-effective technology for
universal surveillance and social control).
|
Frederick W. Taylor
| Invented "time and motion" studies.
|
Ronald Reagan
| De-ment-ed (Sorry, I meant: "deregulated"...) everything he could get his hands on.
(See also his friend: Margaret Thatcher)
|
Ralph Nader
| "Progressive" who gave George W. Bush the presidency in November 2000 election, and
still doesn't feel any responsibility or guilt about having done so.
|
St. Paul
| Father of institutionalized intolerant Christianity.
|
Pablo Picasso
| Probable sociopath.
|
Robert Venturi
| Pioneer of cynical architecture (postmodernism).
|
Karl Abraham
| Freud's lackey. Believed that working class persons
whose symptoms were due to their feeling oppressed or an attempt to escape their
oppression, should to learn to live with their oppression, and not escape it. As
a doctor reviewing miner's disability claims, he had opportunity to implement this conviction.
|
Adolf Eichmann
| Followed orders.
|
Ayatulla Ruhollah Khomeini
| Freed the Iranian people from freedom. Major
force in rise of Islamic neo-fundamentalism.
|
Marie ("Madam") Curie
| Knew X-rays cause cancer but didn't tell anybody, because
she feared the bad publicity would impede their acceptance.
|
Francis Crick and James Watson
| Beat all other competitors to make a big
scientific discovery first, by any means necessary. Tried to get them going down
blind alleys (Linus Pauling). Denied them credit (Rosalind Franklin).
|
Alois Hitler
| Adolf's father. The only member of the family he did not
mistreat was the dog.
|
Joseph McCarthy
| "Tail gunner Joe" (who never got in a military plane except
for publicity photos on the ground...). The man behind the word "McCarthyism".
|
Mahatma Gandhi
| Made his family enjoy(sic) voluntary poverty they didn't want.
May have used nonviolence as way to get others to do violence and then
deny responsibility for it.
|
Werner Herzog
| Makes great films, but doesn't care if people get killed in the process.
|
Jodie Foster
| Actress who played a teenage "slut" in a movie and then
said she saw absolutely no connection when an obsessed fan (John Hinckley) tried to assasinate the President of the
United States to impress her.
|
Pete Rose
| Baseball player who may have killed baseball Commissioner Bart Giamatti with voodoo.
|